Blog

How to Quote Custom Machines Before the Parts List Is Ready

See how manufacturing quoting software can estimate custom machines before the BOM is complete, with clear assumptions and revision control.

By ITHENA ITHENA Insights 7 min read

TL;DR

Manufacturing quoting software can help a machine builder prepare an early estimate before every component is known, provided the estimate separates confirmed requirements from assumptions and allowances. Start with a clear scope, compare the request with similar completed machines, estimate the largest cost areas, and show how unresolved choices could change the price. Label the result as a budgetary estimate until engineering and supplier inputs support a firm quote.

Definition

An early machine quote is a price estimate created while engineering is still defining the equipment and the final bill of materials, or BOM, is incomplete. It can help a buyer decide whether to continue with a project and help a builder plan the next design step. It should state what is known, what is assumed, what is excluded, and what information is needed before the price can be firm.

Manufacturing quoting software may organize the request, estimate, versions, approvals, and customer proposal. The software does not remove uncertainty from an unfinished design. The estimating method and the quality of its inputs still matter.

Key Takeaways

  1. Separate a budgetary estimate from a firm commercial quote.
  2. Record confirmed requirements, assumptions, allowances, exclusions, and open questions in the quote.
  3. Use comparable machine history and measurable design drivers to estimate before every part is specified.
  4. Test how major open decisions could change cost or delivery timing.
  5. Revisit the estimate at defined engineering milestones and compare the final result with actual costs.

Quick Q&A

Can you quote a custom machine before the BOM is complete?

Yes, if the buyer and builder agree that the initial figure is an estimate based on a stated scope and assumptions. The quote should identify open requirements and explain what could change the price. Do not present an early estimate as a fixed price unless the scope and commercial terms support that commitment.

What information is useful before the parts list is ready?

Capture the required output, cycle time, product range, operating environment, available utilities, site constraints, safety requirements, operator involvement, installation location, and interfaces with existing equipment. Also record what the customer has not decided yet.

What should manufacturing quoting software track?

Look for controlled quote versions, source documents, assumptions, exclusions, estimate status, approvals, supplier inputs, and links between the proposal and later engineering or production records. Confirm each capability in a demonstration using your own workflow.

Estimate stage What to include What moves it forward
Concept estimate Known requirements, comparable machine history, major cost groups, assumptions, exclusions, and a price range. Agreement on the concept scope and the questions that could materially change cost.
Design review estimate Updated engineering effort, supplier budget inputs, revised allowances, and a record of changed requirements. Review of the design, interfaces, long lead items, and key supplier responses.
Firm quote Approved scope, validated costs, delivery basis, payment terms, quote validity, and explicit change conditions. Required design and commercial approvals are complete.

Mastering the Engineer-to-Order Estimate

Start with the decision the estimate needs to support.

Before calculating a price, ask what the customer needs to decide. A concept estimate may answer whether the project fits a budget. A later quote may support a purchase decision. Those are different uses and need different levels of detail.

Define the machine boundary in plain language. State what the builder will supply, such as the base machine, guarding, controls, installation, training, or commissioning. List customer-supplied equipment and site work separately. An unclear boundary can make two prices look comparable when they cover different work.

For engineer-to-order projects, the information does not always arrive as a complete parts list. SAP documents a sales process for engineers to order production in which preliminary requirements are created before final BOM transfer. That illustrates why early requirements and later engineering detail should be traceable through the order. SAP Help Portal

Build an estimate from what is known.

Divide the machine into cost groups rather than waiting for every part number. Depending on the project, these may include mechanical and electrical engineering, controls, purchased equipment, fabricated parts, assembly, software, testing, installation, freight, and commissioning.

Use completed machines or projects as a starting point when the scope is comparable. Adjust the reference for measurable differences such as throughput, number of stations, product dimensions, motion axes, operating environment, safety needs, and integration with other equipment. Record the source and reasoning behind each adjustment so another estimator can review it.

Ask suppliers for budget inputs on items that could dominate cost or lead time. For unresolved items, use a named allowance with an owner and a date for confirmation. Keep confirmed supplier prices separate from estimates. This makes the quote easier to revise when actual specifications arrive.

Make uncertainty visible

Create a short assumption register alongside the price. For each item, state whether it is confirmed, assumed, allowed for, excluded, or awaiting a decision. Add who owns the next action and when the estimate should be reviewed.

For example, a custom inspection machine might have a confirmed target rate and product size, but an open camera choice, an unconfirmed connection to the customer's line, and an undecided installation location. The estimator can show the base scope and identify how each open decision affects equipment, controls, travel, or commissioning without inventing a precise cost for unknown work.

The US Government Accountability Office cost estimating guide emphasizes documenting the basis and assumptions behind estimates, checking how changed assumptions affect the result, and updating estimates when the underlying plan changes. It is written for government programs, but the discipline is useful for an early machine quote too. GAO Cost Estimating and Assessment Guide

Use quote versions as design changes

Give each estimate a revision, date, scope, and approval state. When the customer changes throughput, product dimensions, safety requirements, or site conditions, record what changed and why the price or schedule changed with it. Keep the earlier version available so the team can explain the difference.

Set review points that match the work: concept approval, design review, supplier validation, and release for production. At each point, replace assumptions with confirmed engineering or supplier information where possible. Compare the estimate with actual labor and material costs after delivery, then use that history to improve future estimates.

Choose software around the handoff

Some tools focus on estimating parts from drawings or CAD. Others focus on configuring a repeatable product, creating a proposal, or carrying an approved order into engineering and production. A custom machine builder may use more than one approach. Compare how each tool handles incomplete information, quote revision history, approval, supplier input, and transfer into the systems used by engineering and operations.

ITHENA describes industrial CPQ on its iCRM page and CPQ linked with inventory and pricing data, plus multi level BOM cost rollups and versioning, on its iERP page. Its published material does not spell out every preliminary estimate scenario, so ask the team to demonstrate your own quote before the BOM is complete. For ITHENA's broader view of machine builder workflows, see PanelOps and manufacturing workflows.

ITHENA's published demo advice is: “Pick the process that hurts most.” Bring one real machine request and ask the vendor to trace the quote from initial assumptions through engineering review.

Conclusion

You do not need a finished parts list to begin a useful machine estimate. You do need a defined scope, a visible basis, documented assumptions, and a plan to revise the quote as design knowledge improves. The best manufacturing quoting software for your team is the software that supports those controls and carries the approved information into the next stage of work.

Sources

  1. SAP Help Portal: Sales Order Processing with Engineer-to-Order Production: SAP example of preliminary requirements before later BOM transfer.
  2. GAO Cost Estimating and Assessment Guide: guidance on estimate assumptions, uncertainty, sensitivity, and updates.
  3. ITHENA iCRM: published industrial CRM and CPQ descriptions.
  4. ITHENA iERP: published CPQ, inventory, BOM, and project workflow descriptions.
  5. ITHENA PanelOps manufacturing workflows: existing article on machine builders and industrial workflows.
  6. ITHENA contact page: demo and contact destination.

Next Step

Evaluating ERP for your manufacturing workflows? Discuss your quote-to-production process with ITHENA.

Get started

Connect one line. See the deviation before it becomes downtime.

Start with one line on your own data and expand use case by use case.